So I included things such as rush chances, end-to-end rushes, etc… The results aren’t perfect, but until we get the actual speed of every player, this is as close as I could get.īody Checking: I took some creative liberties with this one and decided to go with effective hits, or hits that separate a player from the puck, rather than the pure hits stats as the NHL tracks it. Speed: While the NHL’s chip tracking system isn’t implemented yet, I judged speed by how fast a player could play rather than pure straight-line speed. Here are the attributes I decided to tweak in the end and what I took into consideration for each. This way, there would be no chance of superstars being slotted on the 2nd or 3rd line due to poor defense. So I decided to scale down the edits and try to find a balance between overalls that pass the eye test and adjustments that reflect real-life performance. This in turn led to some wonky lineups when the CPU would go “Best Lines”. Matt Grzezlcyk became an 85 in one of the early iterations, for example, and was nearly as good as Torey Krug, if not higher rated. It would turn a lot of elite offensive talents with average defense into good but not great overalls, and inversely could make some role players jump way up in rating. This issue continued to pop up for pretty much every high-rated player. If I include that same change with the other adjustments I made, he drops down to 86. If I simply drop his defensive awareness by 9 points, he falls all the way down to an 89. Ovi starts out as a 92 in EA’s latest roster update. The problem comes with how that attribute translates in-game. Now, I don’t think that’s too bad of an evaluation for the Russian’s defense. In one of my first iterations, Ovechkin’s defensive awareness graded out at 78. Danault even had some Selke recognition in 2018-19, finishing 7th in voting, including one vote for first place. That’s just one point lower than Phillip Danault, who has established himself as one of the best defensive centers in the game over the past couple of seasons. Yet, his defensive awareness stands at a very good 87. Now, I don’t think anybody would claim Ovechkin is a defensive ace. Anders Lee setting up in front of the net is a smart play, but if Johnny Gaudreau did the same, it would be a waste of his abilities. They are also very vague categories that are tough to quantify and the definition changes from player to player. These two numbers have a huge impact on the final overall and thus, nearly every elite player has a high rating in both. However, I quickly realized that a few stats made this a near-impossible task: Offensive and Defensive Awareness. How can you grade a shutdown defenseman like Niklas Hjalmarsson and a pure sniper like Alex Ovechkin on the same scale?Īt first, I attempted to include as many attributes as I could in my rework. There are so many different ways to be an effective hockey player. Last, and by no means least, boiling every player’s talent to a single number is almost impossible. Second, it was harder to do multiple iterations since, with each attempt, I needed to input all this new data in NHL 20 by myself, as roster sharing isn’t yet implemented. First, the number of players and the amount of data taken into consideration was massive. Coming up with a new system for NHL skaters was by far the hardest part of this whole exercise.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |